RSS

Nerds Heart YA: Rowan the Strange vs. Last Night I Sang to the Monster

20 Aug

It’s the semi final round of the Nerds Heart YA competition! In this bracket, we have:

Rowan the Strange by Julie Hearn vs. Last Night I Sang to the Monster by Benjamin Alire Sáenz.  Both books were very good, which isn’t surprising, since they’ve made it this far in the competition.  Both books feature teen boys in mental institutions, but after that similarity, they are very, very different books.

Rowan the Strange is set in England during WWII.  Rowan is 13 years old, and having an increasingly hard time dealing with the voices in his head– voices that lead him to break his sister’s fingers when she won’t stop playing the piano when he asks.    His family takes him to a hospital that says they can help, using the very latest techniques.  Rowan and another teen, Dorothea, become early test cases for electroshock therapy.  The treatment has some of the expected effects, but the results also offer some surprises.

Last Night I Sang To the Monster is a contemporary novel.  Zach is 18 and in rehab.  He doesn’t know what led to his stay there, and he really, really doesn’t want to remember.  He’s bright and very articulate.  The book is first person, and at times goes into stream of consciousness as he wrestles with his past and present.  His therapy doesn’t get any more experimental than Breathwork, but the effects on him are explosive.

Advancing to the next round is Last Night I Sang to the Monster.

Both books are worthy of advancing, and an argument could be made either way.

Both books feature strong characters, although I’d give Last Night the edge here– both for the main character and the supporting characters.

The books are aimed at different age groups– I’ll suggest Rowan to my 12 year old daughter, but Last Night will wait a few years.

I think Rowan probably has a wider audience, and not just due to the wider age range.  I think most readers will be able to appreciate it, and I can see several reasons that people would reject Last Night.  It has much more of an edge to it, with graphic descriptions of past incidents, in Zach’s life as well as others he’s living with.

This edginess is probably what gave Last Night such an impact, and that’s what my decision comes down to.  I was in tears many times during my reading of Last Night, and even the more intense scenes of Rowan didn’t have that impact on me.  Both books have haunted me since reading them, but Last Night I Sang to the Monster isn’t letting up.

I’m not sure I would have picked up either of these books if it wasn’t for judging this competition, and I’m very glad I did. I’ll be looking at more of the nominated books, and not just the ones that immediately call to me.

Please consider buying both books (or getting them from your library).   Read them.  Review them.  Spread the word!

Last Night I Sang to the Monster will be going up against Say the Word by Jeannine Garsee. Go to Bart’s Bookshelf to find out why!

Lenore from Presenting Lenore is tasked with making the final decision on September 3, and I don’t envy her at all!

Advertisements
 
12 Comments

Posted by on August 20, 2010 in blogging, books, reviews

 

Tags: , , , ,

12 responses to “Nerds Heart YA: Rowan the Strange vs. Last Night I Sang to the Monster

  1. Bart

    August 20, 2010 at 2:44 am

    Looks like it was a really tough choice. Say the Word’s going to have a really tough fight on it’s hands 😀 May the best book win! 😉

     
  2. Lenore

    August 20, 2010 at 3:01 am

    I wouldn’t have predicted this final at the beginning, but it looks like I have some intense reads ahead of me!

     
  3. bookgazing

    August 20, 2010 at 3:19 am

    Thanks for being a judge at the last minute 🙂 It seems like this match up was a bit felicitous as both characetrs are in ‘institutions’ so hopefully there was quite a bit to compare.

    Good luck Lenore – the blogging world is watching you!

     
  4. Amanda

    August 20, 2010 at 6:16 am

    I’m not sure I could handle Last Night I Sang to the Monster, but it sounds incredibly powerful!

     
  5. Pam

    August 20, 2010 at 6:39 pm

    YES! I am rooting for this one. I sent it on too! Fantastic post Laura.

     
  6. Vasilly

    August 21, 2010 at 4:19 pm

    Great post! I am definitely going to read both books. I don’t think I would have picked them up on my own but I’m glad you mentioned them today! 🙂

     
  7. Melanie

    September 13, 2010 at 3:04 pm

    Yay! I picked Last Night too, and I’m rooting for it in the finals. Can’t wait for the final decisions.

     

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: